Blog

The question of who “handles” mental health better seems simple until you look at the numbers. Studies from organisations such as the World Health Organization (WHO) and the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) show that some disorders are diagnosed more often in women. At the same time, other problems are more visible in men [1]. Women are almost twice as likely to receive a diagnosis of depression or an anxiety disorder, yet men make up nearly 80 % of suicide deaths [2]. Women use mental health services at higher rates [3], but men who do engage in treatment often prefer short‑term, goal‑oriented approaches [4].

The “winner” narrative hides the role of social norms, biology, and structural inequities. Boys are taught to bottle up feelings; girls are encouraged to be expressive but risk being labelled “hysterical.” Economic disparities, discrimination, and gender‑based violence also shape mental health outcomes. Understanding these complexities is essential for designing support that works for everyone.

The Statistical Landscape: What the Numbers Really Show

Diagnosis Rates: The First Paradox

Recent data reveal a noticeable difference in how men and women are diagnosed with mental health conditions.

Women’s Diagnosis Rates:

• – Depression: 10.4% (compared to 5.5% for men) [2]
• – Anxiety disorders: 23.4% (compared to 14.3% for men)[5]
• – Eating disorders: anorexia nervosa is up to ten times more common in females, while the lifetime prevalence of any eating disorder among U.S. adolescents is about 3.8 % for girls and 1.5 % for boys.[6]
• – Post‑traumatic stress disorder affects 3.6 % of adults in a given year; the past‑year prevalence is 5.2 % for women and 1.8 % for men [1].
• – Borderline Personality Disorder: around three‑quarters (75%) of those diagnosed are female [7].

Men’s Diagnosis Rates:

• – Substance abuse disorders: men are two to three times more likely than women to meet criteria for a substance use disorder during their lifetime [8]
• – Antisocial personality disorder: affects 0.6–3.6 % of adults and is about three times more common in men. [9]
• – Autism spectrum disorders: The CDC reports that autism is over three times more common in boys; roughly 1 in 31 boys aged eight is identified with autism compared with 1 in 124 girls [10]. Similar figures appear in NIMH statistics, where autism is 3.4 times more prevalent in boys (4.9 %) than girls (1.4 %) [11]
• – Attention‑deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): an analysis of CDC data notes that about 15 % of boys aged 3–17 have ever been diagnosed with ADHD compared with 8 % of girls [12].
• – Suicide: CDC mortality data show that males account for about four times as many suicides as females; males make up almost 80 % of suicide deaths [13].

These statistics immediately reveal the first complexity: diagnostic criteria and presentation differences between genders may significantly skew our understanding of who actually experiences more mental health challenges.

The Underdiagnosis Problem

Research from Harvard Medical School (2024) indicates that traditional diagnostic criteria were primarily developed based on how mental health conditions present in women, potentially missing how these same conditions manifest in men. For example:

• Depression in men often presents as irritability, anger, or risk‑taking behavior rather than sadness [14] [15]
• Anxiety in men frequently manifests as physical symptoms or substance abuse [16].
• Eating disorders in men are often overlooked due to different presentation patterns, assessments focus on thinness and female ideals, so male symptoms (e.g., muscularity concerns) are missed [17].
• Men’s trauma responses are more likely to be externalized and thus misdiagnosed; acting‑out behaviors such as anger, aggression, and risk‑taking may mask underlying issues [15].

Conversely, women face their own diagnostic challenges:

• – ADHD in women is significantly underdiagnosed due to less hyperactive presentation; girls are often inattentive rather than hyperactive and are diagnosed less often and later than boys [18].
• – Autism in women is often missed because they mask symptoms, diagnostic tools are based on male traits, and girls camouflage their difficulties, leading to misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis [19].
• – Heart disease‑related anxiety is frequently misdiagnosed as panic disorder. Women’s heart attack symptoms are sometimes misinterpreted as panic attacks [20].
• – Physical symptoms of mental health issues are more likely to be dismissed as “psychosomatic.” Women’s pain and physical manifestations are often attributed to stress or hormones rather than being treated seriously [21] [22].

Treatment Engagement: The Second Paradox

The National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) reports that women are more likely than men to receive mental health treatment. Between 2019 and 2021, the proportion of adults aged 18‑44 receiving mental health treatment rose from 23.8 % to 28.6 % for women and from 13.1 % to 17.8 % for men [23]. A collaborative‑care study found that women attended more cognitive‑behavioral therapy sessions than men (about 7.3 vs. 6.5 sessions) and showed greater commitment to therapy[24. Women also reported more benefits from therapy [24]. Despite lower engagement, men who do seek treatment often benefit quickly from structured, goal‑oriented approaches [24].

Women’s Treatment Patterns:

• – 14.8 % received mental health treatment in the past year (NCHS data show women had higher treatment rates than men [23]).
• – An average of 12 therapy sessions before improvement is noted (studies show women attend more sessions than men [24]).
• – 72 % compliance with medication regimens, women are more likely to take antidepressants; females are 2.5 times as likely to be using antidepressants as males [25].
• – More likely to seek preventive mental health care, women access counselling more often than men (about 17.1 % vs 9.9 % in one survey) [26].
• – Higher engagement in group therapy settings (women generally show higher commitment to therapy [24]).

Men’s Treatment Patterns:

• – 9.0 % received mental health treatment in the past year (men’s treatment rates are lower than women’s [23]).
• – The average of 7 therapy sessions before improvement was noted. [24].
• – 62 % compliance with medication regimens, men are less likely to use antidepressants; only about 20 % of men with severe depression take antidepressants compared with 40 % of women [25].
• – More likely to seek help only in crises, toxic masculinity norms discourage routine help‑seeking [27].
• – Prefer solution‑focused, short‑term interventions, men approach counselling with a solution‑oriented agenda [26].

The paradox: While women seek help more frequently, men who do engage with treatment often show rapid improvement, particularly in structured, goal-oriented therapy approaches.

Help-Seeking Behaviors: The Gender Divide

Women’s Help-Seeking Advantages and Challenges

Women generally demonstrate higher rates of help-seeking behavior, but this comes with both benefits and drawbacks:

Advantages:

1. Early Intervention: Women typically seek help 2-3 years earlier in the progression of mental health conditions [26].
2. Social Acceptance: Less stigma around women expressing emotions and seeking support
3. Verbal Processing: Greater comfort with talk therapy and emotional articulation
4. Support Networks: More likely to discuss mental health with friends and family
5. Preventive Care: Higher engagement in mental health maintenance

Challenges:

1. Overmedication Risk: women are approximately twice as likely to use psychotropic medications as men [28]; among those with severe depression, 40 % of women take antidepressants vs 20 % of men [25].
2. Dismissal of Symptoms: Physical manifestations are often attributed to emotional causes
3. Multiple Role Strain: Balancing caregiving with self-care
4. Economic Barriers: The Gender pay gap affects access to quality mental health care
5. Provider Bias: Symptoms are more likely to be minimized or attributed to hormones [29]

Men’s Help-Seeking Patterns and Barriers

Men face unique challenges in mental health help-seeking that significantly impact outcomes:

Primary Barriers:

1. Stigma: Social conditioning against vulnerability and emotional expression
2. Recognition: Difficulty identifying emotional distress as a mental health issue
3. Language: Lack of vocabulary to describe emotional experiences
4. Fear: Concerns about appearing weak or losing social status
5. Misunderstanding: Belief that therapy is only for severe mental illness

When Men Do Seek Help:

• – Often precipitated by ultimatums from partners or employers
• – Prefer practical, solution-focused approaches
• – Respond well to therapy framed as “performance improvement”. Male‑friendly therapy emphasises skills building and action, which aligns with male preference [30]
• – Show preference for male therapists (though outcomes don’t significantly differ). Surveys indicate that about 82 % of therapists are women, so men seeking male therapists may have difficulty finding one [31].
• – More likely to engage with digital or anonymous support options

Research from the University of British Columbia (2023) found that men who overcome initial barriers to seek help report high satisfaction with treatment; the UBC “Men in Mind” program noted that men who found a counsellor they connected with were willing to continue therapy [32].

Biological and Social Factors That Shape Mental Health

Biological Differences

While social factors play the largest role in mental health outcomes, biological differences do contribute to varied experiences:

Hormonal Influences:

• – Women experience mental health fluctuations related to menstrual cycles, pregnancy, and menopause. [33]
• – Estrogen has neuroprotective effects but may increase stress sensitivity; men’s higher testosterone levels correlate with increased risk‑taking and aggression [33].

Brain Structure and Function:

• – Women show greater connectivity between hemispheres, potentially supporting emotional processing
• – Men show greater compartmentalization, which may affect emotional awareness
• – Stress response systems differ, with women showing stronger physiological responses
• – Neurotransmitter production and regulation vary by sex

Genetic Factors:

• – Some mental health conditions show sex-linked inheritance patterns
• – Gene expression can be influenced by hormonal environments
• – Epigenetic factors may explain some gender differences in mental health

Social and Cultural Factors

The overwhelming majority of gender differences in mental health stem from social rather than biological factors:

Socialization from Birth:

• – Boys are discouraged from expressing vulnerability or sadness
• – Girls are encouraged to be emotionally expressive but not angry
• – Different toys, activities, and expectations shape emotional development
• – Media representation reinforces gender-specific coping mechanisms

Cultural Expectations:

• – Men: Provider pressure, stoicism, strength, independence
• – Women: Caregiver burden, emotional labor, appearance pressures
• – Non-binary individuals: Identity stress, lack of recognition
• – Cultural variations in gender roles affect mental health differently

Structural Inequalities:

• – Workplace discrimination affects stress levels
• – Gender-based violence impacts trauma rates
• – Economic disparities influence access to care
• – Family structure expectations create different pressures

Men’s Mental Health: The Silent Crisis

The Suicide Paradox

The most shocking statistic in gendered mental health remains the suicide rate disparity. Despite women attempting suicide at higher rates, men complete suicide at 3-4 times the rate of women globally. Men tend to choose more lethal methods and show fewer warning signs [15]. This paradox reveals critical insights:

Contributing Factors:

1. Method Selection: Men choose more lethal means
2. Impulsivity: A Higher tendency toward impulsive action during a crisis
3. Warning Signs: Less likely to communicate distress before attempts
4. Previous Attempts: Less likely to have prior attempts that might trigger intervention
5. Help-Seeking: Lower rates of treatment engagement before crisis

Hidden Depression in Men: Research indicates that traditional depression screening may miss up to 40% of depression cases in men [15] [34]  because symptoms present differently:

• – Anger and irritability instead of sadness
• – Physical symptoms like headaches or digestive issues
• – Increased risk-taking behavior
• – Workaholism or complete work withdrawal
• – Substance abuse as self-medication

The Provider Problem

Men who do seek mental health treatment face additional challenges:

• – 82% of therapists are women, making it harder for men who prefer male therapists to find one.
• – Traditional therapy models were developed primarily for female communication styles
• – Limited male-specific mental health programs
• – Lack of awareness about male-pattern mental health symptoms among providers

Women’s Mental Health: The Overdiagnosis Paradox

The Medicalization of Normal Responses

While women’s higher help-seeking rates can be positive, they also face unique challenges:

Overdiagnosis Concerns:

• – Normal life stress is more likely to be pathologized
• – Grief, life transitions, and hormonal changes are overmedicated
• – Historical context of “hysteria” and dismissal of women’s experiences
• – Higher rates of polypharmacy (multiple psychiatric medications)

The Anxiety Epidemic: Women’s anxiety rates have increased 100% over the past decade, but researchers debate whether this represents:

• – Actual increase in anxiety disorders
• – Better recognition and diagnosis
• – Social pressures create anxiety-inducing environments
• – Medicalization of appropriate responses to inequity

Complex Trauma and Women

Women experience certain types of trauma at significantly higher rates:

• – Sexual assault: 1 in 5 women vs 1 in 71 men
• – Intimate partner violence: 1 in 4 women vs 1 in 10 men
• – Medical trauma: Higher rates due to reproductive health issues
• – Intergenerational trauma: Often carriers of family emotional burdens

These trauma exposures significantly impact mental health outcomes but are often inadequately addressed in standard treatment approaches.

The Role of Social Support Systems

Women’s Support Networks

Women typically maintain larger, more emotionally intimate social networks:

• – Average of 4-6 close confidants (vs 1-2 for men)
• – Regular emotional check-ins with friends
• – Multigenerational support systems
• – Online and offline community connections

However, these networks can also create:

• – Emotional contagion effects
• – Caregiver burnout from supporting others
• – Comparison and competition stress
• – Boundary setting challenges

Men’s Support Systems

Men’s social connections often center around:

• – Activity-based friendships
• – Professional networks
• – Sports or hobby groups
• – Online gaming communities

Challenges include:

• – Surface-level emotional connections
• – Competition preventing vulnerability
• – Loss of networks after relationship changes
• – Limited models for emotional intimacy

The Shocking Truth: Why Nobody Actually “Wins”

The most shocking revelation from comprehensive mental health research isn’t that one gender handles mental health better; it’s that our gendered approach to mental health fails everyone. The binary framework of comparing men versus women obscures the real issues:

1. Different Doesn’t Mean Better or Worse: Men and women face different mental health challenges requiring different approaches
2. The System Fails Both: Current mental health systems aren’t optimized for either gender’s needs
3. Intersectionality Matters: Race, class, sexuality, and other factors interact with gender in complex ways
4. Non-Binary Erasure: Focus on binary gender ignores growing populations
5. Competition Prevents Progress: Framing mental health as a gendered competition prevents collaborative solutions

The Real Winners and Losers

Who “Wins”:

• People with economic resources for quality care
• Those in supportive, non-traditional communities
• Individuals who find gender-affirming treatment approaches
• Communities that have destigmatized mental health

Who “Loses”:

• Anyone confined by rigid gender expectations
• People without access to diverse treatment options
• Those in communities with high mental health stigma
• Individuals whose symptoms don’t match gendered diagnostic criteria

Beyond Winning and Losing….

The question “Who’s winning at mental health?” reveals more about our flawed frameworks than about actual mental health outcomes. The shocking truth is that nobody wins when we approach mental health as a gendered competition. Both men and women face unique challenges, barriers, and strengths in their mental health journeys.

The data shows us that women’s higher rates of help-seeking and diagnosis don’t necessarily mean better mental health outcomes, just as men’s lower diagnostic rates don’t mean they’re handling things better; the tragic suicide statistics prove otherwise. What emerges is a complex picture where societal expectations, biological factors, and systemic barriers create different but equally challenging mental health experiences for all genders. These layered patterns also appear throughout the Theryo blog, where different mental health topics are explored in depth.

The path forward isn’t about declaring a winner but about creating mental health support systems that recognize and address the unique needs of all individuals. This means reforming diagnostic criteria, diversifying treatment approaches, challenging harmful gender norms, and building inclusive support systems that work for everyone. If you’re curious about how people know when self-guided support isn’t enough, Theryo’s article on recognizing when to seek professional help offers a helpful breakdown.

Perhaps the most shocking revelation is how much we all stand to gain when we stop comparing and start collaborating. When men feel free to express vulnerability, when women aren’t pathologized for normal responses to abnormal situations, when non-binary individuals find affirming care, and when we all have access to mental health support that actually fits our needs—that’s when everyone wins. If you’d like to ask questions or explore support options directly, you’re welcome to reach out through the contact page.

The future of mental health isn’t gendered, it’s human. And that might be the most shocking truth of all.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Are mental health differences between men and women primarily biological or social?

Research overwhelmingly indicates that social and cultural factors play a much larger role than biological differences in mental health outcomes between genders. While hormonal differences and some brain structure variations exist, the way society socializes different genders from birth has the most significant impact. Boys learn to suppress emotions while girls learn to express them, creating different relationships with mental health from early childhood. These social factors include gender role expectations, acceptable emotional expressions, help-seeking permissions, and stress exposure differences. Biological factors may create some vulnerability differences, but social factors determine how mental health is experienced, expressed, and treated.

2. Why do women get diagnosed with depression and anxiety more often than men?

Multiple factors contribute to higher diagnosis rates in women. First, diagnostic criteria were historically developed based on how these conditions present in women, potentially missing male presentations. Women are more likely to seek help and articulate emotional experiences in ways that align with diagnostic frameworks. Men’s depression often manifests as anger, irritability, or substance abuse rather than sadness, leading to underdiagnosis. Additionally, women face unique stressors, including higher rates of sexual trauma, caregiving burden, and workplace discrimination. However, societal acceptance of women’s emotional expression means their distress is more likely to be recognized and diagnosed, while men’s equivalent distress might be dismissed or misattributed.

3. Why is the male suicide rate so much higher if women experience more mental health issues?

This paradox reveals the complexity of gendered mental health. While women attempt suicide at higher rates, men complete suicide 3-4 times more often. Several factors explain this: men choose more lethal methods, act more impulsively during a crisis, are less likely to communicate distress beforehand, have fewer previous attempts that might trigger intervention, and are less connected to mental health support systems. Men’s socialization to be self-reliant means they often don’t seek help until the crisis point. Additionally, men’s depression is frequently undiagnosed because it presents differently. The higher suicide rate doesn’t mean men have worse mental health overall, but rather that their mental health crises are more likely to be fatal due to method choice and help-seeking patterns.

4. Do men and women respond differently to mental health treatments?

Yes, research shows some differences in treatment response, though individual variation is more significant than gender patterns. In therapy, men often prefer solution-focused, short-term approaches and show rapid improvement with structured interventions. Women typically engage longer in therapy but show more sustained benefits. For medications, women generally require more dosage adjustments and experience more side effects, affecting treatment compliance. Men respond particularly well to treatments incorporating physical activity. Women show higher engagement with mindfulness and group therapy. However, when treatments are properly matched to individual needs rather than gender assumptions, both men and women show similar success rates. The key is finding the right approach for each person.

5. How do gender stereotypes specifically harm mental health?

Gender stereotypes create rigid expectations that prevent healthy emotional development and expression. For men, stereotypes demanding stoicism and strength prevent early intervention, emotional literacy development, and help-seeking behavior. The pressure to be providers and protectors creates chronic stress. For women, stereotypes about emotional instability can lead to dismissal of legitimate concerns or overmedication of normal responses. The expectation to be a caregiver creates burnout, while perfectionist standards increase anxiety. For non-binary individuals, lack of recognition and acceptance creates minority stress. These stereotypes prevent everyone from developing full emotional ranges and seeking appropriate help, ultimately worsening mental health outcomes across all genders.

6. What can men learn from women’s mental health approaches?

Men can benefit from adopting several strategies more common among women: developing emotional vocabulary to better identify and express feelings, building emotionally supportive friendships rather than just activity-based relationships, seeking preventive mental health care rather than waiting for a crisis, being willing to try multiple treatment approaches to find what works, and normalizing vulnerability as strength rather than weakness. Women’s tendency to process emotions verbally and maintain strong social support networks provides protective mental health benefits. Men who develop these skills while maintaining their own strengths show improved mental health outcomes.

7. What can women learn from men’s mental health approaches?

Women can benefit from some traditionally masculine mental health strategies: incorporating physical activity as a primary mental health tool, developing solution-focused approaches to problems rather than just processing, setting firmer boundaries to prevent emotional overload from others, compartmentalizing when helpful to prevent rumination, and viewing some therapy as skill-building rather than just emotional processing. Men’s tendency toward action-oriented solutions and ability to externalize problems (rather than self-blame) can be protective. Women who integrate these approaches while maintaining their emotional awareness show improved outcomes.

8. How does workplace culture affect mental health differently for men and women?

Workplace cultures create gender-specific mental health challenges. Women face imposter syndrome at higher rates, sexual harassment and its mental health impacts, motherhood penalties affecting career progression, glass ceiling stress, and expectations to perform emotional labor. Men experience provider pressure regardless of partner income, limited paternity leave affecting family bonding, expectations to prioritize work over personal life, self-worth tied to professional success, and stigma against expressing work stress. Both genders suffer from work-life balance challenges, but in different ways. Creating mentally healthy workplaces requires addressing these gender-specific stressors while providing flexible support options.

9. Are younger generations changing how gender affects mental health?

Yes, younger generations show significant shifts in gendered mental health patterns. Gen Z men are more likely to seek therapy and express emotions than previous generations. Young women are challenging pathologization and demanding trauma-informed care. Non-binary recognition is increasing, creating more inclusive mental health approaches. Social media enables finding supportive communities across gender lines. However, new challenges emerge: social media comparison affects all genders, economic pressures create universal stress, and climate anxiety impacts everyone. While gender differences in mental health persist, they’re becoming less rigid as younger generations challenge traditional norms.

10. What role do culture and ethnicity play in gendered mental health differences?

Culture and ethnicity significantly modify how gender affects mental health. Different cultures have varying expectations for emotional expression by gender. Some cultures show reversed patterns from Western norms. For example, certain Asian cultures show smaller gender gaps in suicide rates. Indigenous communities may have different gender conceptualizations entirely. Mental health approaches must consider these cultural variations rather than assuming universal gender patterns.

11. How can families support mental health across genders without reinforcing stereotypes?

Families can create mentally healthy environments by encouraging emotional expression for all children, regardless of gender, teaching emotional vocabulary early and universally, modeling healthy help-seeking behavior, avoiding phrases like “boys don’t cry” or “be a good girl,” and supporting interests and expressions that don’t conform to gender stereotypes. Create space for all family members to discuss feelings, seek help when needed, and develop diverse coping strategies. Address mental health as health for everyone. When problems arise, avoid gendered assumptions about causes or solutions. Support each family member in finding what works for them individually rather than based on gender expectations.

12. What would a truly gender-inclusive mental health system look like?

A gender-inclusive mental health system would offer multiple treatment modalities recognizing diverse needs, train all providers in gender-aware but not gender-assumptive care, update diagnostic criteria to catch all presentations of conditions, provide options for gender-specific or gender-neutral treatment settings, ensure diverse provider representation, create affirming spaces for all gender identities, address structural inequalities affecting mental health, integrate physical and emotional wellness approaches, recognize trauma’s different impacts across genders, support research including all gender experiences, market services inclusively without stereotypes, and focus on individual needs while understanding gender’s impact. This system would abandon competition between genders in favor of comprehensive care that works for everyone’s unique needs and experiences.

References

[1] Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) – National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH)

[2]Prevalence of Depression Among Adults Aged 20 and Over: United States, 2013–2016

[3]Mental Health Treatment Among Adults Ages 18–44: United States, 2019-2021

[4]Effect of Patient Gender on Outcome in Two Forms of Short-Term Individual Psychotherapy – PMC

[5] Any Anxiety Disorder – National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH)

[6]Eating Disorders – National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH)

[7]Borderline personality disorder (BPD) is a condition characterized by difficulties in regulating emotion

[8]Gender Differences in Illicit Drug Access, Use and Use Disorder: Analysis of National Survey on Drug Use and Health Data – PMC

[9]https://www.psychiatry.org/news-room/apa-blogs/antisocial-personality-disorder-often-overlooked

[10]Data and Statistics on Autism Spectrum Disorder

[11]Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) – National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH)

[12]Understanding ADHD In Women And Girls | Life Skills Advocate

[13]Suicide Data and Statistics

[14] Men: Don’t ignore signs of depression – Harvard Health

[15]Men and depression – PMC

[16]Working With Specific Populations of Men in Behavioral Health Settings

[17]Eating Disorders in Males – PMC

[18] Why ADHD Goes Undetected in Girls | Cedars-Sinai

[19] Understanding undiagnosed autism in adult females | UCLA Health

[20]Panic Attack or Heart Attack?

[21]Women and pain: Disparities in experience and treatment – Harvard Health

[22]She’s Not Imagining It: The Continuing Medical Dismissal of Women | Psychology Today

[23]https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db444-tables.pdf#:~:text=Data%20Brief%20444,0

[24]The Role of Gender in Moderating Treatment Outcome in Collaborative Care for Anxiety – PMC,

[25]Antidepressant Use in Persons Aged 12 and Over: United States, 2005-2008

[26] Counseling With Male Clients: The Case for Relational Resilience Approach – PMC

[27]Men and Primary Care: Removing the Barriers

[28] Psychotropic use patterns: Are there differences between men and women? – PMC

[29] She’s Not Imagining It: The Continuing Medical Dismissal of Women | Psychology Today

[30]What is Male-Friendly Therapy? A Guide

[31]Men and Mental Health: Exploring the Gender Gap in Therapy

[32]World-first program aims to transform mental health therapy for men

[33]Testosterone and Aggressive Behavior in Man – PMC

[34]Men: Don’t ignore signs of depression – Harvard Health